Montgomery County Public Schools DAE: Evaluations | Destiny Library Manager

 

Record Information

Type: Reader
Title: Pride Puppy (DISAPPROVED) (Textbook - Please see EPIC record)
Publisher: Orca Books
ISBN: 9781459824843
Copyright: 2021
Author:Stevenson, Robin

Evaluation Information

Recommendation Status: disapproved
Created By:Sandra Steele
Subject Unit:English Language Arts(ELA)-Reading Skills(RS)
English Language Arts(ELA)-Writing Skills(WRS)
Fiction(FIC)
Grade Level:PreK, K, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
Describe the material:Include description of contents and their intended purpose.
 
Origin--Pre-K-12 ELA Curriculum--Melaika Brown--2.26.24. ELA Content Standards 10.10.R.1.1 - Ask and answer questions to demonstrate understanding of a text, referring explicitly to the text as the basis for the answers.
Evaluate the material:What is its relationship to MCPS curriculum?
 
Written by a KidLit author and member of the LGBTQ+ community - A young child and their family celebrate Pride Day by attending a PRIDE parade.
Analyze the material:List material's strengths and weaknesses.
 
Could potentially require teachers to explicitly teach vocabulary terms outside the context of the lesson.
Relative worth of the material:How does it compare (and relate) to other similar materials on the same subject?
 
This requires more explicit instruction of vocabulary and concepts beyond the curriculum standards.
First Signature: Melaika Brown, ELA Supervisor
First Signature Date: 2/23/2024
Second Signature: Niki Hazel, Associate Superintendent
School Number: 008